malewithatail
VIP Member
Posts: 3,963
Likes: 1,380
Location: Northern Rivers NSW
|
Post by malewithatail on Jul 1, 2023 14:22:27 GMT 10
Came across this on Quora, makes some interesting points. dried dog food is cheap, and easy to stor and lasts forever almost.
“What is the danger of a human eating dried dog food for a few weeks?”
My brother spent his entire career as a veterinarian. This is how he explained dog food to me.
Dogs have lives short enough that we were able determine their ideal diet in a few generations. Veterinary schools fed dogs carefully measured food deficient in specific nutrients to determine which ones were essential to dogs.
Then for each nutrient they picked levels and raised dozens of dogs to those levels and tabulated longevity.
Once they had determined the best longevity they experimented to make the formula as cheap as possible that still produced okay longevity. Pet owners know dogs don’t live as long as cats.
Finally they tuned dog food to taste good to dogs. This tends to be liver flavored.
Dog nutrition is slightly different than human nutrition but those needs are very close together. Dogs don’t need vitamin C. Other than that our dietary needs overlap a lot.
Dried dog food smells bad because it is tuned to taste like badly cooked liver because that’s what dogs like.
Other than the flavor you should be able to eat it for years. Your only risk is scurvy from vitamin C deficiency. Maybe not even that as vitamin C is cheap and does act as a preservative.
Dogs do better on low carb than humans do, but dog food has added carbs to make it cheaper. Except for the flavor of badly ruined liver the nutritional profile is even better for humans than for dogs.
The list of essential nutrients might be shorter for dogs than humans. Add a generic brand multivitamin with minerals and you could eat dog food in good health and disgusting taste for many years without getting sick.
Food for thought ?
Dirty Harry. “You don’t assign him to murder cases. You just turn him loose."
|
|
|
Post by Stealth on Jul 1, 2023 14:39:22 GMT 10
Cheeky revolutionary idea... You could stock human food like rice, beans, and a few flavour enhancers like salt and spices, and longer-term fat storage options like ghee (which granted don't last forever, but neither does a bag of dog food) for about the same price in the long term. I'd rather stock human food and need to feed it to my dog than dog food and have to eat it myself. If you're going to add a multivitamin as well anyway you might as well eat something that doesn't make you want to yark before you even eat it. Almost all sources recommend that you mostly stack food that you eat regularly because otherwise you're not going to cycle your pantry through and keep it as fresh as possible. Do you plan to eat a bowl of dog food every day before SHTF to keep changing it out? Cause otherwise it WILL go bad eventually and you'd just have a storeroom full of dog food that's both gone bad AND you didn't want to eat in the first place lol. Now don't get me wrong, if I were starving and it was all that was left and there were no other options I'd probably cringe a bit but I'd eat a handful of dog food without too much second though. BUT I'm sure as heck not stacking a barrel of $50 worth of dog food when I can fill that same barrel with $50 worth of rice and beans.
|
|
frostbite
VIP Member
Posts: 5,719
Likes: 7,119
|
Post by frostbite on Jul 3, 2023 7:05:57 GMT 10
My young grand daughter keeps raiding the dog bowl for kibble. She better not turn into a furrie
|
|
|
Post by Stealth on Jul 3, 2023 11:32:48 GMT 10
frostbite Your comment reminded me of a young lass that I used to know in Primary school who would raid the family dog's bowl every afternoon after school waiting for her mum to get home. Mum worked locally and generally got home after school was out so she was a latchkey kid (like most of us, GenX didn't have the monopoly on that no matter what they tell themselves rofl). So little miss would sit at the back door, patting the dog on one side and snaffling scooby snacks on the other. I remember her telling us like it was some kind of amazing discovery, and she was very confused when a lot of us went mildly green. Apparently the only thing that stopped her was mum swapping over to the type of biscuits that you added hot water to to make a kind of gravy. We used to give them to our great dane, and the smell of it was what instigated my 'making you yark' comment. BLECH! Anyway, little miss didn't like the new powdered variety and stopped eating them. Kids are the best, aren't they? Hahahaha. This thread does bring up a good point though. Survival food for dogs is generally an afterthought for me. We don't have a dog anymore, will probably get one when we move to a new property. But stacking human food that's safe for pets as well is pretty important. I've recently done a batch of raw ox heart for our cat but she's a notoriously fussy eater. She'll eat BITS of heart, lung, whatever other offal, but she much prefers fish. It proves problematic because fish cat food generally has additives and stuff in it to keep them healthy with all-round nutrition but one food source over and over again can lead to nutritional deficiencies. Not to mention our dear old lady (geriatric jerk, is another term I use endearingly for her heh) gets food fatigue in the best of situations. I'm a little concerned about what she'll do in the worst. People say "They'll eat if they're hungry" but if she's had one food too often, she absolutely will not. I used to get frustrated by it because we'd waste so much food until my sister pointed out that it's a common trait for cats to refuse to eat the same thing for more than a few days in a row in the wild because after that the food source is likely tainted by bacteria and would make them sick. Oh. Makes sense. Obviously the same is true for dogs, however they seem to have a far longer tolerance period for bad food risk. I don't even know if multivitamins exist for pets. I have to assume they do. But I also have to assume the cost is ridiculous and that a general regular diet is better. As is the case with people. I envy people with non-fussy animals. My current cat is the only cat I've ever known to be this extreme in her preference. I guess she's closer to her wild nature than the previous housecats I've had. But it does mean that I'm going to have to start prioritizing foods that we can change out frequently. I think I'm going to have to start stacking slabs of several different brands of cans with a few freezedried extras to supplement if I think her nutrition isn't keeping up. And I suppose worst case scenario, we have cases of cat food to turn into meatloaf or mornay if things go bad? 🤣
|
|
frostbite
VIP Member
Posts: 5,719
Likes: 7,119
|
Post by frostbite on Jul 3, 2023 11:44:57 GMT 10
You could feed the cat to the dog, that’ll take care of one problem and delay starvation for the dog a few days. A lot of country people shoot Roos for dog meat.
|
|
tactile
Senior Member
Posts: 1,069
Likes: 483
|
Post by tactile on Jul 3, 2023 12:02:31 GMT 10
This thread does bring up a good point though. Survival food for dogs is generally an afterthought for me. We don't have a dog anymore, will probably get one when we move to a new property. But stacking human food that's safe for pets as well is pretty important. I've recently done a batch of raw ox heart for our cat but she's a notoriously fussy eater. She'll eat BITS of heart, lung, whatever other offal, but she much prefers fish. It proves problematic because fish cat food generally has additives and stuff in it to keep them healthy with all-round nutrition but one food source over and over again can lead to nutritional deficiencies. Not to mention our dear old lady (geriatric jerk, is another term I use endearingly for her heh) gets food fatigue in the best of situations. I'm a little concerned about what she'll do in the worst. People say "They'll eat if they're hungry" but if she's had one food too often, she absolutely will not. Keep an eye out in the 'human' fish tin aisle at the supermarket. Salmon or tuna in spring-water is sometimes cheaper than cat food! Go easy on the Tuna though...cats dont do well with heavy metals that we seem to be able to tolerate. You can rinse it too if you're worried about salt but it would be no worse than the crap in the pet food aisle. Check the cans ingredients for the lowest sodium content.
My cats live over 18 years on this stuff so it hasn't been detrimental to their life span.
|
|
|
Post by Stealth on Jul 3, 2023 12:04:36 GMT 10
It's not really a cat vs. dogs superiority complex. It's simply providing everyone in the household that you love with the best options for them. Be it cat, dog, horse, budgie or husband.
That last one has a little flex, if he's being rude to the cat. She's old. We respect the elderly in our house, regardless of their species. Could be why I'm being so diplomatic about you suggesting that I should murder a loved one.
And yes, I'm well aware that the only reason I'm going to get away with that little bit of banter is that I'm far too far away for you to throw your walking stick at me. 🤣🤣🤣
|
|
|
Post by Stealth on Jul 3, 2023 12:10:05 GMT 10
Keep an eye out in the 'human' fish tin aisle at the supermarket. Salmon or tuna in spring-water is sometimes cheaper than cat food! Go easy on the Tuna though...cats dont do well with heavy metals that we seem to be able to tolerate. You can rinse it too if you're worried about salt but it would be no worse than the crap in the pet food aisle. Check the cans ingredients for the lowest sodium content.
My cats live over 18 years on this stuff so it hasn't been detrimental to their life span.
Good idea! Hubby loves smoked sprats, you should see the cat flip her lid when he opens a tin. She has fancy taste lmao. But the more I look at commercial foods both for cats AND dogs, the more I realise that they probably don't have as good of a shelf life as single-produce canned items like fish. Dogs you get a bit of flex with because they can and should have a variety of veg in their meals as well. But because cats are obligate carnivores, the tinned stuff is getting more and more cereal items in them and it's not going to keep them healthy in the longer term. We have to vary our purchases wildly for our old girl due to her fussiness but she never seems to turn her nose up at tinned salmon when I've given her some so that might be a good option if it's cheaper than the mass-produced pet food version on occasion. Even if it's the same price. We do cycle vet food into her diet as well but she even gets sick of that quickly. Maybe when we get to the forever home and get a dog she'll go back to being less fussy if she has some competition again! Our last dog used to clear her bowl if she wasn't around so she seemed to be less finicky because she knew she'd miss out.
|
|
tactile
Senior Member
Posts: 1,069
Likes: 483
|
Post by tactile on Jul 3, 2023 12:14:42 GMT 10
Sirena Tuna ($$$) and Wollies home brand Salmon in Springwater FTW. We rotate it with other stuff that you probably dont want to know about...
|
|
frostbite
VIP Member
Posts: 5,719
Likes: 7,119
|
Post by frostbite on Jul 3, 2023 12:20:37 GMT 10
You’ll keep, Stealth. No walking stick required, my legs are fine, could use a new right wrist though.
I’ve never been a cat person. They remind me of Americans, self centred, arrogant, aloof. My last interaction with a cat was in May, when I was staying the night at my work wife’s retreat, and her bloody cat wouldn’t stop meowing at the bedroom door. Work wife wasn’t going to get up to let it in, so I eventually did and the bloody thing took off. It just wanted to be a pain in the butt.
|
|
tactile
Senior Member
Posts: 1,069
Likes: 483
|
Post by tactile on Jul 3, 2023 12:45:23 GMT 10
Or maybe it could sense bottomless, unrelenting evil?
|
|
frostbite
VIP Member
Posts: 5,719
Likes: 7,119
|
Post by frostbite on Jul 3, 2023 12:48:48 GMT 10
Or maybe it could sense bottomless, unrelenting evil? You keep showering me with compliments like that and we’ll get on fine.
|
|
tactile
Senior Member
Posts: 1,069
Likes: 483
|
Post by tactile on Jul 3, 2023 18:24:06 GMT 10
My cat can sense it...he stays away from me.
|
|
Tim Horton
Senior Member
Posts: 1,945
Likes: 1,996
|
Post by Tim Horton on Jul 30, 2023 2:25:52 GMT 10
Back in the day when my big brother and I had hunting camps, or when just the 2 of us were out for a day we always carried a version of an ..overnight pack.. If some how we ended up in the bush after dark..
One thing he carried and I eventually got around to taking along also was a couple giant size Milk Bone brand dog biscuits.. None of the ingredients would hurt you.. They were processed cleanly.. Granted you may not get much out of ingredients like bone meal, but on a rare occasion of consumption it would not hurt you...
I guess I kind of understood shooting roos was a local version of subsistence living, hunting ?? Left overs from that for dog food being a secondary thing.. ??
|
|
|
Post by Stealth on Jul 30, 2023 13:07:47 GMT 10
Roo hunting really depends on where you are and what you're hunting them for. Most people hunt them purely because their populations can blow up to extreme proportions. They'll decimate crops, flatten new growth, and eat just about everything tender in sight. And then some. They're a bit like goats only slightly more picky. They like the GOOD stuff. So most folk will hunt them as pests and then occasionally butcher them, but at least where I grew up they were more being culled as pests than hunted for food. And in that case you're right. So long as the carcass is fresh and doesn't seem to be carrying bulk diseases some folks will butcher them for dog food.
Occasionally someone would butcher one or two for home consumption but as the best meat is in the tail you're really probably only going to take that part and move on these days. It's definitely something I'd put in the 'reserve as pet food' category unless it was the only available source of protein. Even then, just like rabbit they're extremely low fat animals so you'd still have to find additional nutrition sources to fill a macro gap. The meat is quite tasty but nutritionally I'd go for something like wild boar even with the risk of parasites etc. because they have a higher fat content. So long as you process any wild meat properly and don't take risks with dodgey looking animals you're probably going to be ok, but I'd put roo meat in the pet food space and boar in the people meat space if I was looking purely at macros.
|
|
Tim Horton
Senior Member
Posts: 1,945
Likes: 1,996
|
Post by Tim Horton on Aug 1, 2023 3:10:20 GMT 10
I'd put roo meat in the pet food space and boar in the people meat space if I was looking purely at macros. = = = = = Tell me more.... In that at times some posters have said there are a number of ...wild, feral... animals seemingly readily available depending on location.. Things said like feral bulls are ...bad, bad, bad... But wild camel is quite good.. ?? Like said a mix that includes feral hog because of the fat available..
Handling at time of harvest, preserving and cooking can confidently take care of harmful germ type issues.. This as long as there are no parasites growing in the flesh issues.. I've seen ..issues.. with North American bears on rare occasions..
|
|
|
Post by Stealth on Aug 2, 2023 11:27:36 GMT 10
I think a lot of it depends on where you live. I've had friends up north who say that they hunt wild boar often for meat. They're obviously quite careful about processing but they're generally ok. But I've had friends north east who've said they've never got a boar that HASN'T been drastically over-infested with parasites of varying types. Roos are (from my limited understanding) also in a similar vein. Wild camel is probably good meat too, I've had had farmed camel before and it was pretty tasty. Again, generally a very lean meat from what I hear.
In honesty I'm looking at it through the lense of relative ease of access to regular food sources though. If it were a SHTF situation I'm not going to quibble on the source of my meat. So long as it's processed properly like you say, you avoid a lot of the concerns. Macros and nutritional balance absolutely come second to just getting food in the first place! We plan when we're in our forever home, to have several dwarf macadamia trees so that we have a regular fat source that will help to fill the gaps if lean game is all we could get a hold of.
I'm sure there's plenty of folks with far more hunting experience than me that might be able to chime in with their opinion on the matter. We used to go ferreting regularly when I was a kid but my hunting experience basically got cut off when the government solution to the population explosion of rabbits was to release a biological solution or two. It was effective for sure, but it definitely made ferreting a thing of the past as there simply wasn't any un-effected animals to trap anymore in our area.
|
|
malewithatail
VIP Member
Posts: 3,963
Likes: 1,380
Location: Northern Rivers NSW
|
Post by malewithatail on Aug 2, 2023 13:41:27 GMT 10
Like all well thought out biological solutions, rabbits are now pretty well immune to mixy, wonder what gunna happen to the cane toad ? and now veroa in our bees ?
We know what we are doing, you can trust us......
|
|
Tim Horton
Senior Member
Posts: 1,945
Likes: 1,996
|
Post by Tim Horton on Aug 4, 2023 8:11:22 GMT 10
I think a lot of it depends on where you live. I've had friends up north who say that they hunt wild boar often for meat. They're obviously quite careful about processing but they're generally ok. But I've had friends north east who've said they've never got a boar that HASN'T been drastically over-infested with parasites of varying types. = = = = I have seen this in the form of a spring season black bear was good eating.. A bear I harvested during that years fall season was horrible before even getting the skin off... It all depends on there diet.. The bad fall bear went to the bone pile by the swamp and I kept my tag and hunted another area.. Both these bears were harvested as they were attempting to make there way into a feed shed or other farm structure they were not welcome in.. Again during hunting seasons..
So the condo dwelling city-ots who think they will just go to the country and snipe ...fill in the blank... and be OK have a lot to learn..
|
|
Tim Horton
Senior Member
Posts: 1,945
Likes: 1,996
|
Post by Tim Horton on Aug 4, 2023 8:17:09 GMT 10
I think a lot of it depends on where you live. I've had friends up north who say that they hunt wild boar often for meat. They're obviously quite careful about processing but they're generally ok. But I've had friends north east who've said they've never got a boar that HASN'T been drastically over-infested with parasites of varying types. === Bloody computer ate my first post.. I have had this happen in that I harvested a spring season bear that came into the yard focused on our small livestock.. It tasted wonderful.. A fall season bear harvested under the same circumstances, feeding the summer in our swamp was horrible and unusable..
|
|